The Important Role of Box Size and Reversal Amount in Horizontal Counts
The Black Book of Day Trading Strategies
1,000 complete strategies · 31 chapters · Full trade plans
In the realm of Point-and-Figure (P&F) charting, the horizontal count stands as a cornerstone for price objective projection. However, the reliability of these projections is not solely dependent on the width of the congestion pattern. The chosen box size and reversal amount play a important, yet often overlooked, role in shaping the chart itself and, by extension, the results of the horizontal count.
The Interplay of Box Size and Reversal Amount
The box size determines the magnitude of price change required to add a new X or O to a column, while the reversal amount dictates the price movement needed to shift from a column of X's to a column of O's, or vice versa. The interplay between these two parameters governs the chart's sensitivity to price action.
- Smaller Box Sizes and Reversal Amounts: Increase the chart's sensitivity, capturing more minor price fluctuations. This can lead to more frequent, but potentially less reliable, trading signals. The chart may appear more volatile, with numerous short-lived trends.
- Larger Box Sizes and Reversal Amounts: Decrease the chart's sensitivity, filtering out minor price movements and focusing on more significant trends. This results in fewer, but potentially more robust, trading signals. The chart will appear smoother, with longer and more defined trends.
The choice of these parameters is a trade-off between sensitivity and the level of market noise one is willing to tolerate.
A Formulaic Perspective on Parameter Selection
The impact of box size and reversal amount is directly reflected in the horizontal count formula:
Price Objective Extension = Number of Columns × Box Size × Reversal Amount
Price Objective Extension = Number of Columns × Box Size × Reversal Amount
As is evident, both Box Size and Reversal Amount are multiplicative factors. A change in either of these parameters will have a linear impact on the calculated price objective extension. This highlights the importance of selecting these parameters with care and precision.
Case Study: Amazon.com, Inc. (AMZN)
Let's consider a hypothetical P&F chart for Amazon.com, Inc. (AMZN) with a congestion pattern of 10 columns. We will analyze the impact of different parameter sets on the bullish price objective, assuming a pattern low of $120.
| Scenario | Box Size | Reversal Amount | Price Objective Extension | Price Objective |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $1 | 3 | 10 × 1 × 3 = $30 | $150 |
| 2 | $2 | 3 | 10 × 2 × 3 = $60 | $180 |
| 3 | $1 | 5 | 10 × 1 × 5 = $50 | $170 |
As the table demonstrates, a seemingly small change in the box size or reversal amount can lead to a significant difference in the projected price objective. This underscores the necessity of a systematic approach to parameter selection, often involving historical backtesting to determine the optimal settings for a given security.
Optimizing Parameters for Robustness
There is no single “correct” set of parameters for all securities or market conditions. The optimal box size and reversal amount will vary depending on the volatility of the asset and the trader's time horizon. A common approach is to use a percentage of the security's price for the box size, such as 1-2%, to adapt to changing price levels.
Ultimately, the goal is to find a balance that filters out insignificant noise while still capturing meaningful price movements. This requires a deep understanding of the security's historical price behavior and a willingness to experiment with different parameter settings.
In conclusion, the box size and reversal amount are not mere settings to be taken for granted. They are fundamental components of the P&F chart that have a direct and significant impact on the horizontal count. A quantitative analyst must approach the selection of these parameters with the same rigor and analytical discipline applied to the rest of the trading process.